Look, you spend a lot of time in the bathroom on your toilet, why not make it comfortable? Choosing the right toilet seat for your home isn’t rocket science, but it’s worth a little research to know what’s available on the market.
Below is our buying guide to help you understand your options, plus we share our top picks. Let us know what you look for in your next toilet seat!
Page Contents
Our Top Seat Picks
› | Runner Up: | Mayfair Slow-Close Toilet Seat |
---|---|---|
› | Kohler White Plastic Toilet Seat | |
› | Mayfair Soft Round Toilet Seat | |
› | Bath Royale Deluxe Toilet Seat | |
› | Bemis Plastic Elongated Toilet Seat |
Main Features to Consider
Below are six main features to consider when deciding the best toilet seat.
★ Soft Close Feature
★ Seat Comfort
★ The Right Material
★ Look for Durability
★ The Appearance
★ Ease of Installation and Maintenance
Reviews of the Best 8 Toilet Seats on the Market
Our team of experts reviewed and gathered facts for the top toilet seats in 2023.
1. Mayfair Slow-Close Toilet Seat – Runner Up
“The Mayfair is an innovative piece available in round and elongated designs to suit a wide range of toilet bowls. Although it is featured in only a single white color, it is a well-thought-out piece.”
- Style: Elongated
- Bowl Shape: Oval
- Material: Enameled Wood
- Slow Close: Yes
- Easy-Install: Yes
- Scratch Resistant: Yes
- Features:
– Seat Fastening System
– Fits all elongated toilets - Dimensions (sourced from manual): 17″ x 14.12″ x 2″
Color Option
- White
Product Documentation
- Product Install Guide (PDF)
- Wood Core
- Easy to Install
- Affordable
- Soft Close Toilet Seat
- Customers Reported the Toilet Seat Being Wobbly
- The Finish on the Seat Is Porous Hence the Seat Absorbs Stains and Odors
- Some Seats Were Reported to Crack in the First Few Months of Use
Verified Buyer Comment
“This is the best toilet seat I’ve ever bought! It’s easy to install, (I’m a 71 year old woman) very sturdy and comfortable, looks nice, and the slow closing feature is perfect! No more slamming closed by accident, just give it a nudge and walk away. I have had this seat for 15 months, and it is still nice and tight. I clean the seat with a disinfectant wipe or spray cleaner with a soft cloth just as I always have with previous seats and haven’t had any problem with the finish wearing off as other reviews have reported; it still looks new after 15 months! This seat gets a lot of use as I share my home with my daughter and 2 granddaughters, and I have a large extended family with multiple grandchildren that visit and frequently use both bathrooms that each have the same toilet seats. I’m impressed that they both have held up so well. I totally recommend this toilet seat!”
2. Mayfair Soft Round Toilet Seat
“We made this Mayfair our second favorite because it splurges on comfort and functionality. If you spend long hours on the toilet bowl for whatever reason, you’d love this seat.”
- Bowl Shape: Round
- Material: Soft
- Easy-Clean & Change hinges: Yes
- Features:
– Eco Friendly
– Soft, cushioned vinyl - Dimensions (sourced from manual): 15.62″ x 15″ x 3.44″
Color Options
- White
- Sky Blue
- Bone
- Black
Product Documentation
- Product Install Guide (PDF)
- Lightweight Yet Well Padded
- Sleek and Modern Design
- Easy to Clean
- Wooden Core
- 1-Year Warranty
- Pricey
- Long Shipping
Verified Buyer Comment
“It’s nice to combine a sturdy, well-made toilet seat with one that is also comfortable.”
3. Bath Royale Deluxe Toilet Seat – Editor’s Choice
“Although many reviews highlight the Bath Royale Deluxe as one of the best toilet seats ever made. We will let you decide if it truly lives up to its reputation or not.”
- Style: Transitional
- Material: Polypropylene
- Bowl Shape: Elongated or Round
- Slow Close: Yes
- Scratch Resistance: Low
- Stain Resistance: High
- Dimensions (sourced from manual): 18.62″ x 14″ x 2.12″
Color Options
- White
- Biscuit/Linen
- Almond/Bone
Product Documentation
- Product Install Guide (PDF)
- Manufacturer Product Listing
- Compact and Simple to Install
- Easy to Clean Inside and Out
- Made From Durable Material
- Plastic Does not Absorb Stains
- The Slow Close Mechanism May Break
- Lack of Customer Support
- Expensive Compared to Other Models
Verified Buyer Comment
“This is my second seat from this company. I bought the first one when I renovated my upstairs bathroom and I loved it so much I bought a second one, as I just renovated my downstairs bathroom as well. It’s been so perfect I knew I had to have them in all the bathrooms. Super comfortable, never comes loose, easy to clean and very modern and fresh looking. The soft close feature is just wonderful and I don’t know how I ever put up with a regular seat all this time. Highly recommended.”
4. Kohler White Plastic Toilet Seat – Amazon’s Choice
“The Kohler brand is making waves in the toilet manufacturing industry for its top quality. And as you can expect, they did not fail with the Kohler White Plastic toilet seat.”
- Bowl Shape: Elongated
- Material: Plastic
- Contoured Seat: Yes
- Seat-mounting holes size: 5.5″
- Hinges: Plastic
- Features:
– Solid polypropylene plastic
– Contoured seat for user comfort
– Quick-Release™ hinge caps snap open and seat pulls forward for removal
– Quick-Attach™ stainless steel fastener allows for top-mount screwdriver only install - Dimensions (sourced from manual): 17.81″ x 14.18″ x 0.75″
Color Options
- White (0)
- Biscuit (96)
- Almond (47)
- Dune (NY)
- Ice Grey (95)
- Sandbar (G9)
- Black Black (7)
Product Documentation
- Spec Sheet (PDF)
- Product Install Guide (PDF)
- Manufacturer Product Listing
- Elegant Design
- Simple Installation
- Easy to Clean
- Available in Several Colors
- Comes in Round and Elongated Shapes
- Seat May Stick to The Skin
- Long Shipping
- Seat Gets Cold in The Winter
Verified Buyer Comment
“We have gone through so many toilet seats in this household in which the bolts would come loose, it was difficult to clean, it wasn’t sturdy or comfortable, etc. So far, this seat hasn’t caused us any issues. It was easy to install, it’s comfortable enough to sit on to do your business, and it cleans up SO nicely. I would recommend!”
5. Bemis Plastic Elongated Toilet Seat – Review Champion
“We cannot skip including a Bemis toilet seat to our list. This brand is known for its stylish, user-centric, yet affordable seats. But their many amazing designs, the Bemis 1500EC takes the cap.”
- Fits All Elongated Toilets: Yes
- Scratch Resistant: Yes
- Material: Enameled Wood
- Style: Closed Front with Cover
- Bowl Shape: Oval / Elongated
- Hardware: Non-corrosive bolts and wing nuts
- Type of Hinge: Plastic twist to unlock and lock
- Features:
– Eco-friendly material - Dimensions (sourced from manual): 17.43″ x 14.12″ x 2″
Color Options
- White
- Cotton White
- Bone
- Biscuit
- Almond
- Venetian Pink
- Fawn Beige
- Ice Grey
- Silver
- Dresden Blue
Product Documentation
- Spec Sheet (PDF)
- Product Install Guide (PDF)
- Easy to Install
- Beautiful Design
- Easy to Clean Inside and Out
- Durable Material
- More Expensive Compared to Other Models
- Poor Customer Support
Verified Buyer Comment
“I wasn’t really sure what to expect with a toilet seat at this price point. Well I was pleasantly surprised. The seat is good quality, is comfortable and was very easy to install. It was a big plus that it is made in the U.S.A.”
6. American Standard Champion Toilet Seat
Every review of “top seats” probably includes the American Standard Champion seat listed for good reasons.
- Bowl Shape: Elongated
- Material: Plastic
- Slow Close: Yes
- Fits All Elongated Toilet: Yes
- Easy-Install: Yes
- Features:
– Unique Easy Lift off cleaning feature - Dimension: 18.69″ x 14.06″ x 2″
“This seat is perfect. I was getting tired of the slamming of the seat that came with the new toilet. This works perfect. Goes down nice and slow. No more slamming. Love it!” “A bidet toilet seat can reduce your toilet paper consumption by 75% or more, and the Genie White Plastic toilet seat makes this possible even more seamlessly.”
“Wanted to upgrade from the inexpensive, add-on type bidet. Figured the all in one bidet and seat would function and feel better. Terrific shut off valve, and this unit took all of 15 minutes to install. Quality components, with a very comfortable seat.” “Another Bemis toilet seat makes it to our best reviewed. The Bemis Grey Lift-Off toilet seat, otherwise called the 1800EC 000, is a great option for anyone searching for functionality, affordability, and style.”
“OMG this was VERY easy to install. I love how the seat locks in place and I’ll never have to worry about it coming loose. It is comfortable to sit on and definitely sturdy – I weigh 260 lbs and feel comfortable that it won’t break. I love it so much I’m going to buy a second one.” Here are some other great features you may want to consider when choosing your next toilet seat. Finding the toilet in the middle of the night can be tricky, especially if you are half asleep. Luckily for you, there are many models that come with a nightlight, which is not just helpful but also adds to the visual appeal of the toilet. Thanks to the invention of the bidet seat, you no longer need to purchase an entire bidet to get the same benefits. Instead, you can simply buy a bidet seat and use it with your toilet whenever you want. Nobody wants to experience unpleasant odors in the bathroom. Thankfully, if you buy a toilet with a deodorizing feature, the toilet will actually help keep your bathroom smelling clean no matter what. A heated toilet seat is a great solution for those cold winter days and nights. When activated, the heater will constantly keep the seat at a certain temperature. While these seats require electricity to function, they can have a huge impact on comfort, especially during the winter. Read our in-depth review article on heated seats. A step beyond soft-close seats, the self-closing function actually automatically closes the seat for you as you stand up. This feature provides a hands-free way to close them, which is perfect for those who don’t want to touch the seat or otherwise are unable to manually close the toilet lid. Sitting on a cold, hard toilet seat can really be uncomfortable. Instead, people have started using cushioned toilet seats to improve the bathroom experience. For example, a cushioned seat can actually relieve pressure on your muscles and make the toilet experience much more comfortable. They can also provide warmth and promote better balance while using the toilet, so there are a lot of benefits to investing in a cushioned seat. Choosing a toilet seat can be an intimidating process at first. However, with our list of options and guidelines, we hope you’ll feel much more prepared when choosing the best toilet seat for your bathroom’s throne. Even if you want a simple replacement for your current model, many manufacturers will sell replacement seats from their website for an easy swap on your toilet. Ultimately, whether you want something that’s durable, easy to clean, comfortable or all of the above, there are a number of great options out there.Color Options
Product Documentation
Verified Buyer Comment
7. Genie White Plastic Bidet Toilet Seat
– Bidet
– Non-electric and no wiring requiredColor Option
Product Documentation
Verified Buyer Comment
8. Bemis Grey Lift-Off Toilet Seat
Color Options
Product Documentation
Verified Buyer Comment
Extended Features of Toilet Seats
Nightlight Feature
Bidet Seat
Deodorizing Feature
Heated Seat
Self-closing
Cushioned Toilet Seat Option
Bottom Line